Thomas/Skarloey

Version 1 (made by Jivio)

 * Edward as Skarloey (Edward and Skarloey are both wise)
 * Henry as Rheneas (Henry and Rheneas are both kind)
 * Thomas as Sir Handel (Thomas and Sir Handel are both blue and cheeky)
 * Percy as Peter Sam (Both Green)
 * Toby as Rusty (Toby and Rusty are both square)
 * James as Duncan (Both Vain)
 * Gordon as Duke (Both Tender Engines)
 * Murdoch as Bertram
 * Duck as Fearless Freddie
 * Trevor as Neil S&MR 2
 * Oliver as Luke (Oliver and Luke are both green)
 * Donald as Mighty
 * Douglas as Mac
 * Hiro as Proteus
 * Stanley as Ivo Hugh
 * Devious Diesel as Smudger MSR 2
 * Diesel 10 as Stanley MSR 2
 * Ian (a fan-made Narrow Gauge Truck) as S.C.Ruffey
 * Bulstrode as Himself
 * Rocky as Himself
 * Wilbert as Silver (from The Magic Spell)
 * BoCo as Victor
 * Harvey as Colin
 * Merrick as Cranky
 * Emily as Madge (Emily and Madge are both female main stars)
 * Rosie as Millie (Rosie and Millie are both cute)
 * Lady as Georgia (a fan-made Narrow Gauge Engine)
 * Molly as Becky (a fan-made Narrow Gauge Engine)
 * Becky as Molly
 * Georgia as Lady
 * Millie as Rosie
 * Madge as Emily
 * Cranky as Merrick
 * Colin as Harvey
 * Victor as BoCo
 * Culdee as Arthur
 * Bertram as Murdoch
 * Lord Harry/6/Patrick as Spencer
 * George as Bulgy
 * Skarloey as Edward
 * Rheneas as Henry
 * Duke as Gordon
 * Duncan as James
 * Bertram as Murdoch
 * Luke as Oliver
 * Rusty as Toby
 * Sir Handel as Thomas
 * Mighty as Donald
 * Mac as Douglas
 * Proteus as Hiro
 * Ivo Hugh (from RWS) as Stanley
 * Fearless Freddie as Duck
 * Peter Sam as Percy
 * Neil S&MR 2 (from RWS) as Trevor
 * Stanley MSR 2 (from RWS) as Diesel 10
 * Smudger MSR 2 as Devious Diesel
 * Mr. Percival as The Fat Controller
 * The Fat Controller as Mr. Percival

Version 2

 * Thomas=Skarloey
 * Percy=Rheneas
 * Gordon=Sir Handel
 * Henry=Peter Sam
 * Toby=Rusty
 * James=Duncan
 * Duck=Ivo Hugh
 * Edward=Freddie
 * Ferdinand=Duke
 * Donald & Douglas=Mighty Mac
 * Diesel=Smudger
 * Bash=Bertram
 * Isobella=Elizabeth
 * Oliver=Luke
 * Rosie=Millie
 * Dash=Proteus
 * Dennis=Neil
 * D261=Stanley
 * Arry=Lord Harry
 * Bert=Godred
 * Spencer=Mike
 * Diesel 10=George
 * Old Stuck Up=Cranky
 * Harvey=Fred

Version 3 (made by ThomasNTUGS)

 * Thomas as Skarloey
 * Percy as Rheneas
 * Gordon as Sir Handel
 * Henry as Peter Sam
 * Edward as Rusty
 * James as Duncan
 * Duck as Freddie
 * Toby as Duke
 * Donald and Douglas as Mighty Mac
 * Diesel as Smudger
 * Oliver as Luke

Version 4

 * Thomas as Skarloey
 * Percy as Rheneas
 * Gordon as Sir Handel
 * Henry as Peter Sam
 * Toby as Rusty
 * James as Duncan (James and Duncan are both vain)
 * Oliver as Ivo Hugh (from The RWS)
 * Duck as Freddie
 * Edward as Duke
 * Donald & Douglas as Mighty Mac
 * Murdoch as Hiro
 * Caroline as Elizabeth
 * Bertie as Thomas
 * Emily as Marge
 * Mavis as Madge
 * Molly as Lewis
 * Rosie as Millie
 * Elizabeth as Caroline
 * Stanley as Luke
 * Daisy as Diana
 * Diesel 10 as Diesel
 * Smudger as Betram
 * Diesel as Smudger
 * Spencer as Stewie
 * Stepney as Brock
 * Dennis as Harmood
 * Lady as Sally

Version 5 (made by smurf3126)

 * Thomas as Skarloey
 * Percy as Rheneas
 * Gordon as Sir Handel
 * Henry as Peter Sam
 * Toby as Rusty
 * James as Duncan
 * Duck as Freddie
 * Edward as Duke
 * Diesel as Smudger
 * Donald and Douglas as Mighty Mac
 * Oliver as Ivo Hugh
 * Derek as Luke

Version 6

 * Thomas as Skarloey
 * Duck as Rheneas
 * Gordon as Sir Handel (Sir Handel was rude in Season 4)
 * Percy as Peter Sam (They both start with P)
 * Edward as Rusty
 * James as Duncan
 * Toby as Duke
 * Henry as Freddie
 * BoCo as Bertram (They both start with B)
 * Hiro as Proteus
 * Bill & Ben as Mighty Mac
 * Diesel as Smudger
 * Oliver as Luke
 * Stepney as Victor
 * Emily as Millie
 * Sir Topham Hatt as Mr. Percival

Version 7 (made by BrittalCroftFan)

 * Percy as Skarloey
 * Henry as Rheneas
 * Toby as Sir Handel
 * James as Peter Sam
 * Edward as Rusty
 * Thomas as Duncan
 * Donald as Duke
 * Duck as Freddie
 * Douglas as Bretram
 * Gordon as Proteus
 * Bill and Ben as Mighty Mac
 * Sir Topham Hatt as Mr. Percival

Version 8 (made by BramGroatFilms)

 * Percy as Skarloey
 * Thomas as Rheneas
 * Duck as Sir Handel
 * Oliver as Peter Sam
 * Stepney as Rusty
 * S.C.Ruffey as Duncan
 * Gordon as Bertram
 * Hiro as Duke
 * Bill as Mighty
 * Ben as Mac
 * Edward as Proteus
 * Murdoch as Fearless Freddie
 * Sir Topham Hatt as Mr. Percival

Version 9 (made by DucktheGWREngineFan9)

 * Thomas as Skarloey
 * Trevor as Rheneas
 * Gordon as Sir Handel
 * James as Peter Sam
 * Duck as Rusty
 * Bertie as Duncan
 * Murdoch as Duke
 * Spencer as Bertram
 * Edward as Fearless Freddie
 * Bill as Mighty
 * Ben as Mac
 * Hiro as Proteus
 * Devious Diesel as Smudger MSR 2
 * Diesel 10 as Stanley MSR 2
 * Sir Topham Hatt as Mr. Percival

Version 10 (made by dcolemanh)

 * Thomas as Skarloey
 * Arthur as Rheneas
 * Duck as Sir Handel
 * Harold as Peter Sam
 * Edward as Rusty
 * Gordon as Duncan
 * Hank as Duke
 * Spencer as Bertram
 * Murdoch as Fearless Freddie
 * Bill as Mighty
 * Ben as Mac
 * Hiro as Proteus
 * Devious Diesel as Smudger MSR 2
 * Diesel 10 as Stanley MSR 2
 * Sir Topham Hatt as Mr. Percival

Version 11 (made by lloydie555reborn)

 * Thomas as Skarloey
 * Fergus as Rheneas
 * Oliver as Sir Handel
 * Duck as Peter Sam
 * Salty as Rusty
 * James as Duncan
 * Edward as Duke
 * Gordon as Bertram
 * Bertie as Fearless Freddie
 * Bash as Mighty
 * Dash as Mac
 * Ferdinand as Proteus
 * The Diesel as Smudger MSR 2
 * Devious Diesel as Stanley MSR 2
 * Sir Topham Hatt as Mr. Percival

Version 12

 * Thomas as Skarloey
 * Percy as Rheneas
 * Murdoch as Bertram
 * Toby as Duke
 * James as Duncan
 * Henry as Peter Sam
 * Gordon as Sir Handel
 * Edward as Rusty
 * Bill and Ben as Mighty Mac
 * Derek as Luke

Version 13

 * Thomas as Skarloey
 * Percy as Rheneas
 * James as Sir Handel
 * Henry as Peter Sam
 * Toby as Rusty
 * Gordon as Duncan
 * Edward as Duke
 * Duck as Freddie
 * Donald and Douglas as Mighty Mac
 * Oliver as Ivo Hugh
 * Diesel as Smudger
 * Diesel 10 as Stanley MSR 2

Version 14 (made by SonicJrandSarah)

 * Toby as Skarloey
 * Edward as Rheneas
 * Thomas as Sir Handel
 * Percy as Peter Sam
 * Henry as Rusty
 * James as Duncan
 * Gordon as Duke
 * Duck as Fearless Freddie
 * Sir Topham Hatt as Mr. Percival

Version 15 (made by BertietheBusfan14)

 * Thomas as Skarloey
 * Percy as Rheneas
 * Gordon as Sir Handel
 * Henry as Peter Sam
 * Toby as Rusty
 * James as Duncan
 * Edward as Freddie
 * Old Puffer Pete (from Chuggington) as Duke
 * Hoot and Toot (from Chuggington) as Mighty Mac
 * Diesel as Smudger
 * Duck as Ivo Hugh (from RWS)
 * Oliver as Luke
 * BoCo as Victor
 * Sir Topham Hatt as Mr. Percival

Version 16 (Made by ThomasandFriendsfan)

 * Thomas as Skarloey
 * Percy as Rheneas
 * Gordon as Sir Handel
 * Henry as Peter Sam
 * Toby as Rusty
 * James as Duncan
 * Ferdinand as Duke
 * Edward as Fearless Freddie
 * Donald and Douglas as Mighty Mac
 * Oliver as Luke
 * Duck as Ivo Hugh (From RWS)
 * Diesel 10 as Stanley/No. 2 (From RWS)
 * D261 as Smudger
 * Emily as Millie
 * BoCo as Victor
 * Stephen as Bertram
 * Lady as Proteus
 * Nelson as Madge (I know Nelson is Male)
 * Sir Topham Hatt/The Fat Controller as Mr. Percival

Version 17 (Made by Mr. Petley) (DO NOT EDIT, ADD OR DELETE!)

 * Thomas as Skarloey
 * Percy as Rheneas
 * Gordon as Sir Handel
 * Henry as Peter Sam
 * Edward as Rusty
 * James as Duncan
 * Toby as Duke
 * Edward as Fearless Freddie
 * Donald and Douglas as Mighty Mac
 * Duck as Luke (Duck and Luke are both green)
 * Oliver as Ivo Hugh (From RWS)
 * Diesel 10 as Stanley/No. 2 (From RWS)
 * Diesel as Smudger
 * Emily as Millie
 * BoCo as Victor
 * Stephen as Bertram
 * Lady as Proteus
 * Mavis as Madge
 * Sir Topham Hatt/The Fat Controller as Mr. Percival

Version 18 (Made by Isaac jenkin29) (DO NOT EDIT, ADD OR DELETE!)

 * Thomas as Skarloey
 * Percy as Rheneas
 * Henry as Peter Sam
 * Gordon as Sir Handel
 * Edward as Rusty (Both Edward and Rusty are helpful)
 * James as Duncan (Both James and Duncan are vain)
 * Toby as Duke (Both Toby and Duke are old and kind)
 * Duck as Fearless Freddie
 * Donald and Douglas as Mighty Mac
 * Oliver as Luke
 * Emily as Millie
 * BoCo as Ivo Hugh
 * Diesel as Smudger
 * Mavis as Madge
 * Stephen as Bertram
 * Lady as Proteus
 * Sir Topham Hatt as Mr Percival