My Little Pony/Peter Pan

Cast

 * Pinkie Pie as Peter Pan (Rainbow Dash is a bad choice because she isn't funny enough)
 * Rainbow Dash as Wendy Darling
 * Octavia as John Darling
 * Sweetie Belle as Michael Darling
 * Shining Armor as Mr. George Darling
 * Princess Cadance as Mrs. Mary Darling
 * Rarity as Tinkerbell
 * Chief Thunderhooves as The Indian Chief
 * Little Strongheart as Tiger Lily
 * Lord Tirek as Captain James Hook
 * Trixie as Mr. Smee
 * Scootaloo as Slightly
 * Apple Bloom as Nibs
 * Snips and Snails as The Twins
 * Spike as Cubby
 * Pipsqueak as Toodles