• Charlie Bucket as The Nostalgia Critic
  • Violet Beareguarde as The Nostalgia Chick
  • Augustus Gloop as Ma-Ti (Human)
  • Mr. Bucket as Todd In The Shadows
  • Mr. Salt as Lord MacGuffin
  • Mike Teavee as Paw
  • Mario (from Mario) as Chester A Bum
  • Mr. Teavee as Cinema Snob
  • Sonic (from Sonic) as Linkara
  • Grandpa Joe as Phelous
  • Buster Bunny (from Tiny Toon Adventures) as Angry Joe
  • Plucky Duck (from Tiny Toon Adventures) as Jew Wario
  • Willy Wonka as Benzaie
  • Tails (from Sonic) as Spoony
  • Mrs. Bucket as Marzgurl
  • Mrs. Gloop as Dr. C Tease
  • Mrs. Beareguarde as Dr. C Block
  • Bass (from Megaman) as General Zod
  • Snively (from Sonic) as Douche McKnitPick
  • Dr. Robotnik (from Sonic) as Dr. Insano
  • Donkey Kong (from Mario) as Ma-Ti 
  • King Dedede (from Kirby) as Prick
  • Shao Kahn (from Mortal Kombat) as Terl
  • Montana Max (from Tiny Toon Adventures) as Casper
  • Veruca Salt as Mara Wilson
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.