• Bert as Shrek
  • Ernie as Donkey
  • Betty Lou as Princess Fiona
  • Huxley as Prince Charming (Not Grover, because Grover is good, and Prince Charming is bad)
  • Mr. Johnson as Lord Farquaad
  • Abby Cadabby as The Fairy Godmother
  • Grover as Pinocchio
  • Oscar as Puss In Boots
  • Luis as King Harold
  • Maria as Queen Lillian
  • Elmo as Gingy
  • Big Bird as Dragon
  • Cookie Monster as Gingy's Giant Friend
  • Savion as Artie
  • Anastasia Tremaine (Cinderella) as The Ugly Stepsister (Not Oscar, because Oscar is male, and the Ugly Stepsister is female)
  • Donald, Jose and Panchito (The Three Caballeros) as Three Little Pigs
  • Shere Khan (The Jungle Book) as Big Bad Wolf
  • Dingodile (Crash Bandicoot) as Rumpelstilskin (not the Count, because the Count is good and Rumpelstiltskin is bad)
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.