Cast[]
Version 1 (Total Drama Island edition)[]
- Gwen as Twilight Sparkle
- Lindsay as Fluttershy
- Izzy as Pinkie Pie
- Bridgette as Applejack
- Leshawna as Rainbow Dash
- Heather as Rarity
- Sierra as Sunset Shimmer
- Beth as Starlight Glimmer
- Courtney as Trixie Lulamoon
- Cody as Spike
- Trent as Flash Sentry
- Sadie as Derpy Hooves
- Eva as Bon Bon
- Katie as Lyra
- Noah as Dr. Whooves
- Owen as Cheese Sandwich
- Trent as Shining Armor
- Harold as Braeburn
- Tyler as Soarin
- Geoff as Thunderlane
- Justin as Snails
- Ezekiel as Snips
- Alejandro as Discord
- DJ as Big Macintosh
- Duncan as Fancy Pants
Version 2 (Total Drama Revenge of the Island edition)[]
- Dawn as Twilight Sparkle
- Zoey as Fluttershy
- Dakota as Pinkie Pie
- Staci as Applejack
- Jo as Rainbow Dash
- Anne Maria as Rarity
- Blaineley as Sunset Shimmer
- Brick as Flash Sentry
- Mike as Spike
- Cameron as Cheese Sandwich
- Sam as Shining Armor
- B as Dr. Whooves
- Scott as Braeburn
- Lighting as Soarin
Version 3 (Total Drama Pahkitew Island edition)[]
- Scarlett as Twilight Sparkle
- Ella as Fluttershy
- Sugar as Pinkie Pie
- Jasmine as Applejack
- Sky as Rainbow Dash
- Sammy as Rarity
- Amy as Sunset Shimmer
- Topher as Flash Sentry
- Dave as Spike
- Shawn as Shining Armor
- Rodney as Big Macintosh
- Leonard as Cheese Sandwich
- Beardo as Braeburn
- Max as Discord
Version 4 (The Ridonculous Race edition)[]
- Ellody as Twilight Sparkle
- Miles as Fluttershy
- Kitty as Pinkie Pie
- Carrie as Applejack
- Stephanie as Rainbow Dash
- Jen as Rarity
- Taylor as Sunset Shimmer
- Tammy as Starlight Glimmer
- Devin as Flash Sentry
- Junior as Spike
- Noah as Shining Armor
- Owen as Cheese Sandwich
- Mickey as Dr. Whooves
- Jay as Braeburn
- Josee as Derpy Hooves
- Crimson as Trixie Lulamoon
- Emma as Octavia
- Kelly as Princess Celestia
- Mary as Princess Luna
- MacArthur as Lyra
- Sanders as Bon Bon